Does the hyphen syphon equality?

by Randy Zuniga

I forget how old I was when I first learned that I am Mexican. This to me is not necessarily a bad thing — depending on how the information is presented. You can easily shape a child’s perception of specific people or put a chip on their shoulder at an early age. What is that going to do for them? Ultimately, it will affect the way they build relationships growing-up and in school. Understandably, later on down the line they will wise up to the realities of society; so no need to pollute their minds early on with what we think. That inhibits progress, but I digress.

When explaining my background my grandmother always told me, “you are American of Mexican descent.” It wasn’t until I just wrote that sentence a few seconds ago that I realized how deep it truly is. It’s a strong, strong statement declaring that I am contributing member to American society and deserved to be treated as an equal American citizen; it also embraces my rich family heritage – which is significantly different than identifying as “Mexican-American.”

I have an issue with the hyphen. African-American. Asian-American. Mexican-American. Second-Class. While it gives me the outward appearance that we are able to embrace our culture when we identify our nationality, I feel that by adding the hyphen we allow a degree of separation from what society identifies simply as “American.” I’m American, too. Why do we have to be a sub-category or sub-classification of what type of Americans we are?

Maybe the greater issue of identity lies in the question, “What does it mean to be an American, really?” So much effort goes into figuring out what everyone is because there is no real definition of what American is — to each his own. The beauty of this country is its diversity; its downfall is equality.

You would think equality would have been a standard by now. Some may argue it is, which to some extent is true. The rest of us would say there is still a long road ahead to reach that point. Equality is something that will never be achieved over night on the mass level. It starts at the individual level; how we raise our children. Teaching them we are equal, and in order to be respected as an equal we must treat all people equal, ourselves. Embracing our differences culturally or superficially, but being accepting and open-minded with other cultures — has proven to be more difficult than it sounds. I truly believe racism and prejudice are taught in the home; children aren’t born with these ideas or misconceptions. If we want change how we are perceived, it starts with us. In our homes. Educating our future.

To learn more about Randy, visit Iamrandyz.

______________________________________________________________

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of
the author and should not be understood to be shared by Being Latino, Inc.

______________________________________________________________

facebook twitter youtube images

______________________________________________________________

7 Comments to “Does the hyphen syphon equality?”

  1. Randy,
    That was very well stated. I definitely agree with you, and thank you for sharing.
    Take care,
    Marcos

  2. President Woodrow Wilson would have agreed with you. He said: “Any man who carries a hyphen with him carries a dagger that he is ready to plunge into the vitals of this Republic whenever he gets ready.” Then again, that man was a tremendous bigot.

    I understand your point – really, I do – but differences in background/culture/race go deeper than semantics of self-identification, and to deny them causes more problems than it solves; this is illustrated by the fact that other countries that don’t hyphenate like we do (Argentina, the United Kingdom…) face the exact same problems we do.

  3. I love that you identified the psychological implications of a hyphen. Yes, I want to be connected to family history and culture without society/government treating me as a second class citizen.

  4. Hey Randy,
    thanks for summing it up so nicely. Also, the more diverse a family becomes, that hyphen habit starts to sound like a pedigree… My ethnically mixed youngsters say simply “American”.

  5. Great article! It wasn’t until my Freshman year of college when I truly thought about “am I Puerto Rican or American of Puerto Rican decent”. When I talked to my mother about this she told me I am American of Puerto Rican decent which makes sense because I was born and raised here. It’s just interesting when people ask you what nationality you are people would respond Mexican, Black, Italian, but we don’t say oh I’m American- (nationality) because its implied.

  6. Why not hyphenate if we identify strongly with our country of origin or country of heritage? The outright embrace of country of origin/heritage countermands any agreement with the idea that such a heritage warrants second-class status.

  7. Good article, Randy. I agree.. :0) I’m an American because I was born in this great nation but have Mexican roots.